The new romantic comedy Under the Stars demonstrates that assembling all the right ingredients does not guarantee a successful film. Despite a charming Italian backdrop and a cast that includes well-known supporting actors, the movie struggles to feel authentic or engaging.
The story follows a romance novelist who finds himself in an unexpected situation that leads to a potential new love. On paper, the premise has all the hallmarks of a classic feel-good story: scenic locations, a light musical score, and a plot designed to bring two people together. Yet, the execution feels mechanical, lacking the spontaneity and warmth that define the genre’s best offerings.
A significant issue lies in the central relationship. While the lead actors are visually perfect for their roles, their on-screen connection fails to generate believable chemistry. Their interactions often feel staged and unconvincing, making it difficult for the audience to become invested in their journey.
The film’s script also contributes to its uneven tone, with certain choices feeling out of step with a modern romantic narrative. While the picturesque Italian setting provides a visually stunning backdrop, it ultimately serves as a beautiful frame for a story that never truly comes to life.
Under the Stars is a reminder that charm and authenticity cannot be manufactured, even with a proven formula and an idyllic location.
